| Religion and the
American Way of life
Carl F. Mengeling,
Bishop of Lansing
Like the Founders, do I believe that these
truths come from the Creator - that they are immutable and permanent because they are
based on God, not a group of men? With conviction and courage, our Founders risked
everything and signed!
The truths that motivated the Founding Fathers
and provided justification for independence from England were clearly understood and
mutually agreed upon by all the Signers of the Declaration of Independence of July 4,
1776. In their minds, these truths were a firm basis for a long and bitter war for
freedom. Their "American Proposition" could be launched with optimism and hope
because it was based on "self-evident truths" for all time - unchangeable truths
that originated in the Creator, not in man.
For these men, freedom for all absolutely
depended on certain truths that were valid for all and applicable to all. These truths
would guarantee freedom. Because there is no true freedom without truth, our Founders were
not hesitant to declare: "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are
created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights,
that these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness."
They knew that the price tag for true freedom
is responsibility. Our Pledge of Allegiance "with liberty and justice for all"
becomes reality for all only through those who exercise their freedom responsibly. These
self-evident truths were so supreme that the Founders were willing to declare war and risk
their lives. If I had been one of them, would I have signed? For them it meant
treason and death. Franklin wrote to Hancock: "We must indeed all hang
together, or, most assuredly, we shall hang separately."
independence is deeply rooted in the American
psyche. We are the "land of the free." We are a freedom-loving people. Freedom
is at the heart of our American identity, but it is not freedom from truth, from
responsibility and from coexistence with others. Parading today under the banner of
freedom is personal autonomy. It is a gross declaration of independence for people to do
whatever they desire. There are no truths but my own. There are no rights but my own.
The word "autonomy," derived from
Greek, means "self-law" - auto is self and nomos is law. When autonomy disguises
itself as freedom, we are in a crisis on every front and no one is secure. Skepticism
about truth and relativity about value has resulted in this caricature of freedom called
autonomy - the freedom to do what I desire. The "self-evident truths" are now a
threat and obstacle to my freedom.
John Paul 11 said to the new
Ambassador to the Holy See in 1997, "It would be sad if the religious and moral
convictions upon which the American experiment was founded could be considered a danger to
free society" Our Pope tells us that the principles of our Founding Fathers are now
considered by some Americans to be a threat to a free society.
John Courtney Murray, Sj.,
writes in We Hold These Truths "Our Founding Fathers thought that the life of
man in soucity under government is founded on truths, a body of objective truth,
universal in its import, accessible to human reason, definable and defensible. If this is
denied, the America Proposition is, I think, eviscerated in one stroke."
Washington, Franklin, Adams, Hancock,
Jefferson, Hamilton and all the rest hear an echo of their vision for America in the
Farewell of John Paul 11 in Detroit on September 19, 1987. "The best traditions of
your land presume respect for those who cannot defend themselves. If you want equal
justice for all, and true freedom and lasting peace, then,
America, defend life! All the great causes
that are yours today will have meaning only to the extent that you guarantee the right to
life and protect the human person - feeding the poor and welcoming refugees, reinforcing
the social fabric of this nation, promoting the true advancement of women, securing the
rights of minorities ... Every human person - no matter how vulnerable or
helpless, no matter how young or how old, no matter how healthy,
handicapped, or sick, no matter how useful or productive for society - Is being
of Inestimable worth created in the image and likeness of God. This is the dignity of
America, the reason she exists, the condition for her survival - yes, the ultimate test of
her greatness: to respect every human person, especially the weakest and most defenseless
ones, those as yet unborn."
|